Holding "justice still exists « DavidCadogan.ca Forums

DavidCadogan.ca Forums » DavidCadogan.ca

Holding "justice still exists

(1 post)

Started 10 years ago by 89g9kS4lA0S

Tags:

89g9kS4lA0S
Member

Li Kaijiang said: Fu Granny is out of "good intentions" congratulatory letter. Our reporter Jiang Yan After 19-year-old university student Li Kaijiang Zhengzhou propped up lying on the ground Granny Song,http://www.blogharbor.com/cgi-bin/page.cgi, last year was the first instance verdict Song Granny over 79,000 yuan compensation. Li Kaijiang what is "helpers" or "gave the driver?" The traffic police department can not identify responsibility, the court is also difficult to restore the facts, the plaintiff and the defendant will not be able evidence. Only with "Civil Law" in the "fairness" verdict. Many people find it difficult to accept this result, we believe such a ruling,http://www.xmarks.com/s/site/www.tadayumi.sakura.ne.jp/apeboard_plus.cgi/, the future may no one dared to help others, leading to "social morality back 30 years." Li seek help at the same time media, Song Granny was more than anger to the media in collective eat "cold shoulder." True or false, confusing. The emergence of witnesses, can not prove that Li Kaijiang butt? Li Kaijiang is helping people or butt? It happened in more than a year ago. When at 15:14 on August 21, 2008, 17-year-old Li Kaijiang riding electric Reaching River Medical overpass in the northwest corner, suddenly heard the "bang", he felt something rub on the back of his car. I turned to look, a bicycle and hit his rear wheel electric vehicles. An old lady sitting on the ground, kept his mouth issued a "ouch" sound. Li Kaijiang said: "I did not hesitate to help her in the past, may soon help her up, the old lady grabbed me said,doudoune moncler femme, 'You hit my waist up'." At the time, gathered onlookers have accused Granny "Pengci." Song Granny's argument is with them vary widely. Granny Song said in an interview with the media said, with a woman on the back seat of Li Kaijiang car, speeding emergency line, handlebar hit her waist, her car carrying the man knocked to the ground. September 3, 2008, Zhengzhou City, Henan Province, traffic police detachment of the Third Brigade issued a "traffic accident." Confirmation Display: After the scene, investigation,http://brc.riken.jp, can not be verified by the accidents Li Kaijiang,piumini moncler sito ufficiale, Song Granny fault which caused one of the parties. The two sides different attitude towards the media December 28, 2009, Henan Province Erqi District court verdict,http://technoresto.org/cgi-bin/forum/dcboard.cgi, saying that "investigation found that can not be verified by Li Kaijiang or Song which fault caused by one of the parties,http://www.chrisadamsperfumes.com/index.php?item/create_form/1, according to the principle of fairness, the court held that the plaintiff Song reasonable part of the loss from each party to bear 50% more properly. Hence judgment Song Li Kaijiang 15 days to pay 10,000 yuan in emotional and other costs totaling 7.9 million yuan. " January 6, Li Kaijiang and his father to the local media for help, hoping to find witnesses at the time, also own an innocent. Lee actively help the media and different, Song Granny after the first interviews to the local media interviews, on reports that a great deal of anger,http://www.associationflainoise.fr/spip.php?article164, according to local media-related told reporters that she had strongly protested to the newspaper that reported significant "one-sided" tendency. And since then no longer interview with the media, as long as one claiming to be a reporter heard the call, hang up the phone immediately. Later, reporters once again call her cell phone, is not no answer, is not connected. Song repeatedly call the reporter a few days Granny phone, get back are moving the company's voice prompts, saying "can not be connected." Five witnesses said he's willing to testify in court Zhengzhou Li Kaijiang thing after local media reports, soon have five witnesses called at the time to contact the newspaper or Lee Father Li Kaijiang expressed their willingness to testify, to prove that he is innocent. Li Kaijiang father has made contact with three people, he said, the other two witnesses, one attitude on the phone vaguely expressed hearing time to say; there is a person living in a foreign country, he has not been contacted, only know This witness just returned to work the day of passing the scene. We have contacted the three witnesses were expressed then can testify, one of the witnesses Dou Keqin Li also written testimony to the parent. But she accepted an interview with local media reporters after seeing reports Granny Song said, "Witness Lee are friends and relatives," I felt a lot of pressure, no longer willing to be interviewed. Also two witnesses willing to testify Li parent representation, did not want to deal with the media. "Witness the phone I will not say that again with no one." Father Lee worried provoke anxious to witness, no longer willing to testify for his son. He also said that before the trial he will not contact with the witness, "touch more, people will say it is not that friends and relatives, Renyankewei ah." Feel "justice still exists." Since the case of this matter, Li Kaijiang one have become very discouraged, "Now nothing of social morality, human conscience gone?" Father Lee said, before the accident, had never thought about doing so. 1991 born Li Kaijiang feel just as bad. Court summons affected his civil service exam, a verdict made him nothing had a thought. Holding "justice still exists," the idea that he and his father went to the newspaper to find the witnesses, Li Kaijiang said:. "Mentioned throats of the heart to the whereabouts of a lot, to prove his innocence feel there is hope." Students said that he became a "celebrity." To him about it, the students view into two parts,http://www.wifigx.com/forum.php?mod=spacecp&ac=blog&blogid=, some people think he's done right, although to get into a lawsuit, but on social justice still exists, after all, who promised to help him to testify more than one of the two; Another part of people think he nothing good to yourself and others trouble. Now, Li Kaijiang bus did not dare to give up your seat. He said: "As an outsider, much less attitude walking down the street and therefore a non-relative, see also did not see.." Li Kaijiang parents are operatives, together monthly wage is only about 1700 yuan, face huge compensation, a man with a worried frown. Father Lee said the family no one thought to cook,moncler Outlet, hungry to chew bought bread. "My parents encourage each other." Li Kaijiang said,http://qlx.464nk.com/thread-5465791-1-1.html, "I have been doing ideological struggle for the future way to go,piumini moncler sito ufficiale, on his own view of society, life and values,piumini moncler sito ufficiale, are rethinking." January 12, Li Kaijiang appealed to the Intermediate People's Court of Zhengzhou City, Henan Province, accompanied by his father, and is currently waiting for the results. [Focus] key is to see how Granny fall Li Kaijiang eyewitness testimony can help repay innocent? Shanghai Xinhua reporters interviewed the lawyer even Yan Jie. ■ cases unproven focus Yan Jie think even if no witnesses and any interested party, then the probative force of the testimony of witnesses is still relatively strong. "But what are these witnesses witnessed the whole process, or just to see Li Qufu Granny this process?" Even Yan Jie said, if the latter, a little trouble. "The key is to see how the fall of the old lady, otherwise the focus of testimony can not prove the case. At present the testimony of these two witnesses have this problem." ■ should be possible to restore the facts Even Yan Jie pointed out that responsibility can not be identified due to the traffic police department, the fact that the courts can not be restored, so only the first instance verdict adopt the principle of fairness. On the case itself, he believes is justified from a legal perspective. "Because of lack of forensic capacity, if you let Granny Song evidence, she could not evidence; let Li Kaijiang proof did not hit her, it is difficult." "But I personally believe that fairness is a very vague concept, civil law should be used with caution, if there is any evidence capable of reducing the facts, the court should do as much as possible the investigation and screening." Even Yan Jie think, if we are all so sentence, the consequences that no one would have dared to helpin the. ■ How to prove indeed at the scene? So, how to prove that the witness was indeed present? Yan Jie said even if the attendance of witnesses, the court will ask a lot of questions on the details. Judge comprehensive judgment witnesses words and actions are reasonable. If the witness is lying, there is no way to say these details very smooth. Song Granny's lawyer also look at some of the problems can be designed witness said is true. "If the old woman alleged witness Li Kaijiang family friends and relatives, to prove by her." Even Yan Jie said. ■ Lee questioned the sense of drugs Li Kaijiang father to the hospital and pharmacy invoice Song Granny report submitted in the first instance, asking the question: she went to the pharmacy to buy medicine, did not specify the name of the drug on the invoice, specifications, quantities, only the total cost. Yan Jie think he even questioned justified. The court should be invited to the hospital to identify what caused the old lady's injury is how is the old injury or a new injury caused heavy impact. Or let the old lady described how kind being hit, allowing doctors to determine the presence or absence could cause such damage. "In Shanghai, after the injured party may not feel free to go their own prescription, we must rely on the patient card. Submit evidence to the court, it must also have a medical card and drugs to be effective." 

Posted 10 years ago #

RSS feed for this topic

Reply

You must log in to post.