Criminal cases in backward regions more attention

DavidCadogan.ca Forums » DavidCadogan.ca

Criminal cases in backward regions more attention

(1 post)

Started 10 years ago by fglksouIO2b1

Tags:

fglksouIO2b1
Member

Cai Yongjie much media attention the case of the trial scene photo Yangcheng Evening News reporter Zhou Wei Cai Yongjie (middle) was sentenced to three years, suspended TRANSACTIONS OF intake Yangcheng Evening News reporter Dong Liu correspondent Ma Weifeng 53-year-old Ding Yang excuse under the robe, as if to remove the stately courtroom, finally relieved. Where he had just concluded a collegial panel together public opinion was so hot cases. During the trial, "worried" word repeatedly jumped out of his mouth. Bo Xilai case, lei zhengfu case, "Cousin" Yang reached before the case, Beijing fell to infanticide, the airport bombing,louboutin soldes femme, Nanjing starved girls case, "room t" case ...... just past 2013, favored by public opinion Cases abound. Identity public rights of vulnerable groups and disparities between officials, chess and Law, such cases will be pushed to the cusp of public opinion. And in such cases, "surgeon" - On both ends of the judge to face balance "is not", "Love and Law," the measure, once the slightest mistake, they themselves may be involved in the whirlpool of public opinion: if sentenced Well, it can play a leading effect of good and evil. Doing so may cause strong dissatisfaction of public opinion, this dissatisfaction menacing, the judge often overwhelming. There are ten thousand pairs of eyes behind "Courageous" but the owner kindly helped a disservice killed people, events quickly gaining media attention. And on the "Love and Law" measure and judgment, so the judge handling extra cautious This is a case of public opinion from the beginning it followed step by step, from time to time Forced case. At 8:00 on September 19, 2011 more than 48-year-old Cai Yongjie Guangzhou citizen driving a car with his mother to drink tea. When reaching the Baiyun District, Guangzhou Baiyun Avenue from Howard Road gas station ready to refuel, the scene took place just inside the petrol station he saw: a uniformed station staff, are catching up with a man holding a bag of casual. Within noisy gas station, came the "grab things ah" sound. Cai Yongjie robbery that took place, on the open carrying their 77-year-old mother's car, in the "robbers" collision. "The robbers' car was pressure on the bottom of the vehicle after the collision and dragged several meters, the car hit a roadside trees before stopping. But subsequently accused employees of the gas station, knocked the man is the manager of the gas station, and uniformed men chasing people mentally ill, not the robbery occurred. Hit the "robbers" were rushed to hospital, but died a still. After the incident the next day, the Guangzhou media made a widely reported, and sometimes led to public hot. Internet users became a "judge": most users expressed sympathy for Cai Yongjie behavior, that the court should commutation process; there are Internet users believe that this incident should let people on the "courageous" for reflection, encounter specific things should pay attention to the ways and means, I can not see justice is blind. Trial Court Building, 20th Floor,http://www.ad.cyberhome.ne.jp/~k-morita/clip/papalani.cgi, Guangzhou City, is a criminal court judges office area. Judge Ding Yang open hands holding a sessile comb, sitting in the office slightly on the old sofa, habitually head fiddle up. 53-year-old, he, in Guangzhou City Intermediate People's Court sentence of a court has been there 10 years, and for many years his desk,http://www.oka-soft.net/cgi/bbs/aska.cgi/?post=r00&, his forehead hair somewhat sparse. Previously, he worked in the military court trial. "Before hearing the case, we know it a popular social concern." Ding Yang open side with a comb giving her head sideways, told reporters that while he is aware of this case from the media, when the trial lawyers of both parties They are referred to the relevant reports. Pile ordinary criminal cases, due to the attention of public opinion, become extraordinary. Long before the formal hearing, the deputy president of the court, reminded the Full Court Criminal Tribunal hearing to be careful and pay attention to public opinion. October 26, 2012, the case was the first trial, the media coverage once again, the network has set off a tidal wave of public opinion. May 27, 2013 after six months, when the second trial, as the presiding judge Ding Yang opened, after the finish of the trial program, good-naturedly told the court: "(The case) the legal effect we do not speak, To sentence the words are easy. But now, the two sides calmly accept the verdict, the judge is for the best results. "He said the case has not fully pursue only legal effect, but also consider the social effects. Behind the face of thousands of cases of double compelling eyes, how to judge the case, it is placed in front of three judges of the Full Court Ding Yang opened where a problem. "Fish and bear's paw" to eat it In addition to professional judgment, the greater the pressure from the consideration of social effects, a judge said the trial of media attention the case, at any time may be subject to public condemnation. Also a judge because of "once bitten" and "twice shy." Compared to ordinary cases,http://my.5754.cn/home.php?mod=spacecp&ac=blog&blogid=, a high degree of media attention on the case, especially in cases involving law conflict situation, the judge need to pay more. Such cases first qualitative difficult. Initially, the public security organ considers Cai Yongjie alleged negligence causing death, prosecutors prosecute the crime of intentional injury places, families of the victims considered to be intentional homicide, there are users that sentence as not conducive to promote courageous spirit. at his trial that he did not constitute the crime of intentional injury, which belongs to the imaginary defense counsel that should be the fault causing death. The complexity of the case, can seen from the expert team. To Mozhun qualitative case, Ding Yang opened recall that in 2013 the second trial after the September 26,http://classetice.fr/spip.php?article266, Vice-President Wang Jian led the court to invite NPC deputies and CPPCC members, experts, Samaritan Foundation staff, traffic police, together with the court sentence of a court deputy President, a total of three full court judge more than a dozen people, take Pakistan to the site of the incident view. List of experts,scarpe hogan, Professor Wang Xuepei Guangdong University of Business Studies, Zhongshan University Law School professor and associate professor Yang Hong Nie Lize, Zhujun Jiang Guangzhou University Law School professor and two lawyers. In Criminal Tribunal Wan Yunfeng opinion, such an unprecedented lineup. Procuratorate prosecution said Cai Yongjie dragged the victim 13 m, prosecution and the defense to intense controversy dragged 13 meters, 13 meters is how come? Site visits should solve this problem. Back to court, a simple case seminar began. Ding Yang open recall, scholars factions inside view is very clear, tit for tat, and even eat Shihai in controversy. School of scholars sympathetic, compassionate defendant, proposed to broadly protect the courageous; and those who are firmly opposed, saying that the right to life to establish the supremacy of the idea, to prevent the society "under the guise of the name of courageous, to achieve the purpose of personal revenge" behavior. After discussion, combined with the evidence and the law, the Full Court ultimately finds Cai Yongjie behavior is intentional injury. "We went to the scene after measure, finally did not identify dragged 13 meters." After conviction and sentencing is. Ding Yang open that promote justice from the perspective of their own or try to sympathize with Cai Yongjie. After the first trial a mediation, the parties tougher attitude, differences were too great, the two sides had to postpone and continue to do the work, while twice referring a case to the CRIC discussion. "A lot of pressure," said Ding Yang opened, 10 times after mediation, the court basically Mozhun bottom line both sides: the victim side started asking the court to sentence the accused for more than 10 years, later requested that lose money; the accused belong to the families hope finds Cai Yongjie Samaritan. Ultimately, the court agreed to help them: Cai Yongjie families out 600,000 yuan to the families of victims, the families of victims to respect the court's decision in criminal part. "So we think he (Cai Yongjie) have surrendered, crimes are relatively light, the following sentence in legal punishment, sentenced to two years four months directly on it. But then given the current legal provisions can not be minus two block sentencing, intentional injury causing death sentence is more than 10 years benchmark, have voluntarily surrendered themselves minus a block between 3-7 years sentence, three years is minus two-block, minus two-block generally approved by the Supreme Court. Taking into account applicable laws On obstacles, society and the media do not necessarily understand, Cai Yongjie finally sentenced to three years imprisonment, suspended for four years. " Ding Yang opened, said the judge by mental stress, mainly because the trial results by social stigma. Accompanied by a warning to let Ding Yang opened exceptionally cautious. He said that before the judgment day, he received a court notice said the next day to arrange media interviews. That night at home, he let his wife torn paper wall calendars, stay up all night to write a draft of a statement, more than 7:00 the next morning and brought her to court, so that the President, "the gatekeeper." For sound, the leadership of the atrium or the deletion of the word draft. This concern is not unfounded. Some judges have been public since the injury, "once bitten, twice shy." Who had last been heard much national attention the case of a pile of Guangdong judge sentence after the court because they have been interviewed during misreading network, blamed by the users, for a long time can not be relieved. When a reporter interview requests made to him, he think twice,http://bronestlyonnais.fr/spip.php?article46, or declined. & Nbsp; Mature eco opinion Weigh "Yes" and "not", "love" and "law", so they hate, extreme deeds and acrimony farewell network, you need a high-quality team of judges and a mature eco opinion "Justice is a continuous improvement process, it is self-media age, interactive information is very developed, such changes compared with the previous maximum of asking the court is open." In the last year, the trial had been "chased Guangzhou Hawker neck pinch" a Haizhu District of Guangzhou City Court Administrative Chamber Vice-President of the case of Li Yong emotion. The relationship between public opinion and judicial, Wan Yunfeng have their own feelings. As Criminal Tribunal, Wan Yunfeng or PhD Criminal Law of the People's University of China, has been involved in the trial include a second pharmaceutical plant in Qiqihar, including a major counterfeit case, public opinion had also been attacked. Wan Yunfeng too early to hear one case: 3 high school junior high school students robbed a cell phone, two of whom were minors, because it is the court sentenced to probation, another person who just turned 18 years of age, taking into account her own suffering hepatitis, his father suffering from cancer, his mother by laundry livelihood, was the eve of college entrance examination, Wan Yunfeng judge sentenced her to probation. Today, Wan Yunfeng still feel that this decision in favor of her family and of her personal role. However, after media coverage, the network of public opinion raging. "If there are 100 threads, then there are 80 judges are accused, 20 are posts. Criticize the judge's praise, nothing but friends say the judge secret operations, money friends." Ten thousand Yunfeng said. "The court is certainly not about public opinion, the trial court will be concerned about public opinion, public opinion will not be around." In the eyes of ten thousand Yunfeng, a number of legitimate public opinion,louboutin pas cher, while others - like part of the thread on the network - is due on the merits do not understand the cause of the non-rational, truly understand the truth of the case, rational citizens would not say something like that. "I think both the public and the judiciary is not a fundamental antagonistic relationship." Ten thousand Yunfeng said. There are positive and negative public opinion, there are rational but also irrational, as a judge, public opinion can not be excluded, nor fear of public opinion. Ten thousand Yunfeng said that a country's legislation, is to learn the will of the people and society and the development of positive public opinion, with the good law itself is to represent the will of the people. For the good of the demands of public opinion or the right, the judge going concern, a bad or negative opinion, have the courage to face. He felt that the judge must also strengthen their legal knowledge, accurate conviction and sentencing. A concern or dispute a good case if it is determined, it can play a leading effect on society of good and evil. There are similarities with the Guangdong Provincial High Court Criminal Chamber of four red into the valley views. In the valley of red into opinion, the judge should properly treat public opinion,http://cdurable.info/spip.php?article3192, public opinion, insist on the criminal policy of combining punishment with leniency, and strive to achieve legal and social effects of unification. The judge hearing the case in the process, to promptly report the House leadership, and coordination with the relevant authorities, to fully understand the problems reflected public opinion, for the source of the problem, using various means to deal with. It belongs to the scope of the trial, according to the law firm, and deal with the aftermath. Also, pay attention to public opinion, the initiative to communicate with the media, with a positive attitude to achieve Case Closed things. There are experts interviewed also said that a farewell vocal opposition, extreme behavior, public trial mature public opinion environment, to create a good social environment and trial environment is also essential. It is understood, Cai Yongjie case because the defendant did not appeal, prosecutors did not protest, has now entered into force. Ding Yang open to reporters, the defendant's family to send a banner Procuratorate, and did not send to the court. After that, he laughed. Criminal cases in backward regions more attention Just past 2013, the case apparently just one of many nationwide public opinion aroused by one of the hot cases. Only in September 2013, more than in the country has a significant influence cases have trial or sentencing - Bo Xilai case, lei zhengfu case, "Cousin" Yang reached before the case, Beijing fell to infanticide, the airport bombing Nanjing case and other hot girls starve case dizzying, September has thus called "trial month." One common point in these cases,louboutin femme, is subject to widespread public opinion, sustained attention. Responding to the thinking, the Guangdong High Court Criminal Chamber of four red into the valley has written an article entitled "Mode of media attention to the case tried," the article focuses on one aspect of a public presentation of media coverage of the case to bring Impact. Red into the valley mentioned, in recent years, the media has reported on the results of the previous sentence, before sentencing gradually transformed into a broader, deeply involved in the case. Valley red into that in recent years,http://tanukitam.seesaa.net, the trial has become a case of public prosecution essential part of media coverage. Guangzhou newspaper from year to focus on the circumstances of the case analysis of criminal cases reported in the newspapers almost every day, even if there is no case to the public prosecution case, there will be on public prosecution case to comment; where concern for society is particularly hot cases strong, "people of concern is to be reported in the media." "From the current media reports, the Shenzhen Liang case, drag racing in Hangzhou, Hubei Deng case and so on, because of the media for 'eye-catching' reports point to make the case quickly became the center of public opinion, the media seems to itself as the guardian of justice , the trial of the case 'straight from the heart',moncler outlet italia, to a certain extent on the performance of three points: First, make sensational style reports, trying to highlight the fact that a part of; the second is an opportunity to present the views and opinions of one party to the law; the third is taken out of context , the conclusion of the case at random, will be charges. " The emergence of such "national judge", the judge hearing the case to bring some trouble. Sometimes "the trial judge has been unable to independently complete tasks," Gu into wrote red. After analysis of past cases, the red into the valley also draw a conclusion: in real life, justice plays a role right from wrong, and for criminal cases where the poverty and backwardness of what happened,http://onigdesign.com/error.html, the more play the role of the spirit of judicial pillar, this case also When more attention, especially other authorities to respond to their interests and needs did not succeed, the parties opposed to thinking that the greater power injustice. Media, which played a role in a declaration on behalf of the people, if the trial of the case and kind citizens or reporters, who generally consistent awareness okay, otherwise it will cause strong dissatisfaction of public opinion, this dissatisfaction menacing, contractors Judges often overwhelming. (Original title: Canton owners "courageous" killed people sentenced to imprisonment for 3 years (Figure)) 

Posted 10 years ago #

RSS feed for this topic

Reply

You must log in to post.