<br>Yangzi Evening News suspicion only because shrimp cage was moved, 45-year-old Ding Mou and two high school students under 16 years of dispute. Quarrel, the 14-year-old Mary impulse riding the rails, said that if Ding is not to insult the students apologized, she is not down. In the train "rumbling" approaching a critical juncture, Mary brought down by a train, seriously injured died. Mary Ding family then reported on the court. Yesterday, Xuzhou City Intermediate People's Court of Final Appeal ruling, Ding shall bear 70 percent responsibility, compensation of nearly 20 million.<br> <br>Case review<br> <br>Girls sit pique tracks "Do not apologize I do not come down," I was really hit the oncoming train<br> <br>This bizarre event occurred May 14, 2011 in the afternoon, with the Xinyi Wayao Zhenmou Mary attending school and being together Xiaofang students attend dinner. Mary was only 14 years old, but not with her peers Xiaofang to 16 years old. On the day at 1 pm, when they pass near the town Cao,doudoune moncler, he walked suddenly heard someone behind him swearing.<br> <br>The two girls go back to how it was found that a middle-aged man Dingmou positive side check brook shrimp cage, while pointing Xiaofang said she had the shrimp moving cage. Xiaofang immediately and men dispute, Mary for the students to complain, and soon joined the brawl.<br> <br>Three more noise the more fierce, 45-year-old Ding Mou, then more and more ugly. Under agitation, Mary turned rail fence, sit directly on the tracks, requirements and Ding swear, unless Ding apologize to them, or not under the tracks. Unexpectedly, Ding still and the two continued to argue,http://www.poly-tank.net/peoples/taewan/bbs/apeboard_plus.cgi?%3C/a%3E%3C/apeboard_plus.cgi?command=viewres&target=4405780/, neither apology nor persuade Mary to leave the tracks. Soon the tragedy happened, a train "rumbling" fast approaching, are Mary and Ding Mou pique dodge,http://www.88822.com/#03666/read.php?tid=980, brought down by a train at the shoulder of the road, then you seriously.<br> <br>After the accident, Xiaofang and nearby villagers who heard quickly stepped forward to rescue Mary, Mary, but unfortunately the final result of his injuries or death. Mary in the rescue process, Ding Mou always sit on the sidelines, even alone back home afterwards.<br> <br>Quarrel lead to an accident,tn requin pas cher,http://211.86.128.2/gjjl/Review.asp?NewsID=595, who bear responsibility<br> <br>Court<br> <br>He knocked the girl to the families of those noisy claimants<br> <br>When the accident occurred,http://ishukone-raata.net/forums/activity, Mary was only 14 years old, is a third-year graduating students. Family distraught after learning the bad news, Mary father thought Ding as adults, only a little "unwarranted" small, publicly insulted two underage girls, feeling out of control causing Mary riding the rails tragedy,http://211.86.128.2/gjjl/Review.asp?NewsID=595, Ding Mou fault is the direct cause of the accident.<br> <br>Mary father Ding consultation after numerous experiences of finding the claim is rejected,moncler sito ufficiale, the Ding sued Xinyi City People's Court, requesting the court shall order the Dingmou 216,100 yuan compensation for death, funeral expenses 20,252 yuan, 50,orecchini tiffany,000 yuan in emotional ,http://wx.jazzsynth.com/wxcgi/kizai/sunkizai.cgi?mode=form&no=99&page=", transportation costs 1000 yuan, a total of 287,352 yuan.<br> <br>In the first instance, Ding Mou argued: because ditch shrimp cage is turning things do occur two had a disagreement with Mary, but Mary abuse, nor its bet that Mary's death was an accident, in their own accident without any fault, it should not be liable for damages.<br> <br>First instance verdict<br> <br>Girl killed Ding knocked bear responsibility Qicheng<br> <br>Xinyi City Court after hearing the view that Ding chores and Mary because when there is a dispute, could not properly handled, Ding on the risk and possible consequences after Mary entered the rail, we should have a full understanding and adequate foresee, Ding did not apologize, nor take positive and effective measures to persuade the victim to leave the rescue tracks, but also with words of shock, resulting in the victim Mary was moving train hit lethal. Accordance with the law, a comprehensive analysis of the tortfeasor and the victim's degree of fault in the accident, by the defendant to bear 70% of the responsibility is more appropriate, so the decision to compensate the plaintiff Ding funeral expenses, death compensation and other 195,646.4 yuan. After the first trial, Ding refused to accept the appeal to Xuzhou City Intermediate People's Court, the victim said they were not any fault of the death of Mary, it should not be liable, requires the court to revoke the first instance verdict the second instance, commuted First Instance dismissed the plaintiff.<br> <br>Final judgment<br> <br>Yesterday's final judgment upheld<br> <br>Yesterday, the Court of Xuzhou hearing of the case, the court held that, consistent with the second trial of first instance to identify the facts and the facts found, Ding is not enough awareness of their previous abusive behavior may cause harm to Mary,http://211.86.128.2/gjjl/Review.asp?NewsID=595, not to small Li apologized and did not discourage it leaves tracks, eventually leading to death Mary was hit by a train. As a party to the dispute, there is a fault Ding Mou's behavior, the presence of their abusive behavior and death of Mary certain causal relationship,http://kaito1412.com/kid/bbs/apeboard_plus.cgi?command=viewres&target=801162/,peuterey outlet, should bear the corresponding tort liability, the appellant's grounds of appeal can not be established. Xuzhou City Intermediate People's Court rejected the appeal made by law, upheld the final judgment. It is worth mentioning that, in the case of minors, the identity of Mary has become an important factor settle a lawsuit, the trial judge said that because Mary was a minor, for their actions lack sufficient knowledge and judgment, and therefore as small adults It should be recognized that some serious consequences of their abusive behavior may be caused, in other words, if Mary has grown, so, she would need to take more responsibility for their actions. Yangzi Evening News reporter Ma Asia correspondent Zhao Jing<br> <br>(Original title: Girls sit rail knocked angry quarrel died court decision "on those noisy" bear responsibility for 70%)<br><br>
DavidCadogan.ca Forums » DavidCadogan.ca
252 yuan
(1 post)-
Posted 10 years ago #
Reply
You must log in to post.