<br>□ trainee newspaper reporter Wang<br> <br>80-year-old take the subway escalator after the fall in public places responsibility managers dispute the grounds, Hangzhou Hong Kong MTR Corporation Limited to court, claims the loss, including medical expenses, including a total of 2.9 million yuan . The Court of Appeal can be supported?<br> <br>"Legal Daily" reporters today from Zhejiang Jianggan District People's Court heard the case after hearing the October 8 after the decision was made recently. The court finds that the defendant has done to the security obligations within reasonable limits, without tort liability, but in view of the plaintiff has been 80 years old, the defendant, as a public service enterprises, voluntary according to the plaintiff requested 30% of the amount of the plaintiff to compensate, where appropriate, order the defendant to compensate the plaintiff 8800 yuan.<br> <br>It is understood that since the opening of the Hangzhou subway, many passengers have been hurt. Hangzhou Metro passengers prosecution of cases including the present case, including this year, has two cases, one case had been under the District People's Court in Hangzhou,air max 90, the mediation settlement agreement, while the Riverside District Court judgment became Hangzhou Metro "public trial of the first case."<br> <br>Old Man: escalator too fast<br> <br>Fall old Wang, who lives in the Riverside area in the Pavilion, hale and hearty, often a person to go around the bus. Hangzhou after the subway opened, she began to take the subway travel.<br> <br>February 16 this year, Wanglaotai from Jiubao Station subway to Zhalongkou Station.<br> <br>The same day around 8:25, Wanglaotai from Zhanong Kou subway station A exit the escalator, the escalator suddenly feeling a little jump, catch yourself not strong handrails Zuodao, rolled down to the bottom of the elevator, but also with the elevator to lift catchy. Fortunately, passengers will Wanglaotai hold, and to call for help and subway security staff Wanglaotai was able to escape.<br> <br>Subway surveillance video showed Wanglaotai at 8:25:45 fall, fall after 40 seconds, the elevator reaches the catchy; 8:27:12 MTRC security elevator to reach the accident scene at the first port 15 seconds to reach the elevator catchy.<br> <br>Wanglaotai was then taken to a nearby hospital for treatment, diagnosed as mild head trauma That concussion, scalp hematoma, scalp laceration and bilateral distal radius fracture, multiple soft tissue injuries. Hospitalized more than 10 days to continue rehabilitation, May 25 home recuperating.<br> <br>After rehabilitation, Wanglaotai to the courts. August 26, Riverside District Court accepted the case, on October 8 in the eighth open court hearing was heard.<br> <br>During the trial, Wang Laotai agents believe escalators Hangzhou Metro Line 1, for passenger facilities up and down subway stations, the Corporation Hangzhou Metro Line 1 of managers, should provide a safe passenger car matching facilities, since the defendant escalator slope steep, fast, has repeatedly hurt the elderly fall accident, the defendant has failed to pay attention, do not have the obligation to guarantee the safety of passengers, the plaintiff to safeguard their legitimate rights and interests, it is prosecuted.<br> <br>Agents also believe that the incident occurred, no escalator side management to take timely emergency brake and lift speed of 0.65 meters per second, exceeding the national and European standards 0.5 meters per second; the elevator pitch much greater than 50 degrees, from the national standards and personal comfort speaking, 30 degrees is the most appropriate; the defendant in order to save space, will raise the pitch elevator,http://rehabili.godream.ne.jp/cgi-bin/bbs14/bbs14.cgi, exceeding the national standard of 30 degrees, therefore,http://jssts.jp, the defendant should bear the corresponding liability.<br> <br>Enterprise: done security duty<br> <br>Escalator is too fast or standing elderly have a problem? Whether the Corporation to make the security obligations of the administrator of a public place? Old bear personal injury liability whether the legal basis? The focus of debate around the court more.<br> <br>The Corporation's agent source said Shen Tao, plaintiff v. Attorney inconsistent with the fact that the plaintiffs fall because of its violation of the "Hangzhou subway riders Code" Article VII, no right to stand, while the left-leaning body and head stuck elevator the left side of the security zone, the body and the left armrest taken off the safety shield friction, caused by the rising speed of the body is less than the elevator up speed, loss of balance due to inertia, after dumping ground.<br> <br>Shen Tao source said, the plaintiff conscious after the fall, sitting on the elevator reaches the top of the elevator, a cleaner station and a security guard heard the call for help immediately rushed to the scene, then chief duty,http://zencart-pro.com, station staff quickly arrived at the scene, the plaintiff on a wheelchair sent to a nearby hospital for treatment. In the meantime, the station asked that their families by telephone and informed the families of staff also advance the day of 354.2 yuan in newly diagnosed medical expenses.<br> <br>Reporters learned that,http://0to1.info, after the incident,http://store.shopping.yahoo.co.jp/ebest-dvd/0000001121516.html, the Corporation immediately stop using the elevators and notified the elevator manufacturers, the manufacturers to be sent to the scene to detect,ugg saldi, confirm elevator trouble-free recovery after use.<br> <br>To this end, the Corporation also evidence, said from the day's video and elevator maintenance company's feedback letter can be seen that the upstream end of the elevator subway Zhalongkou Station A is uniform throughout the entrance of steady state operation, there is no beating shock, emergency stop turn, unsteadiness, etc., and the elevator pitch and speed are also in line with relevant national standard design, installation, escalator mouth floor clean dry and free of stains water stains, good lighting, the elevator without any obstacles and third human interference, floors, walls, escalator handrails on both sides were significantly boarding warning signs.<br> <br>Shen Tao source said that after the incident, the defendant to take timely relief measures, facilities and services meet public areas manager security obligations requirements.<br> <br>As the subway escalators faster than the mall this issue,hogan outlet, Shen Tao source explained: "This is because different purposes, various factors to set the elevator speed, in line with relevant national standards because of high traffic public areas. slow speed will not reach the passenger requirements, so set at 0.65 meters per second. It is understood that in Beijing, Shanghai subway elevator speed will be set at 0.65 meters per second, the Hong Kong subway elevator speed of 0.75 meters per second,http://sixsixsix.s90.xrea.com/cgi-bin/bbs/epad.cgi/mailto:ixlwsae@outlook.com, fast, then slow down the slope accordingly. "<br> <br>Court: The Company undertakes no responsibility<br> <br>The day of the trial lasted a half hour. During the court investigation, the judge to the plaintiff's agent, the agent asked defendant more than 20 issues.<br> <br>Court found that the plaintiff take the escalator, the rated speed of 0.65 meters per second, the inclination angle of 30 degrees, are in line with GB16899-2011 escalators and moving walkways manufacture and installation of safety norms, the defendant in the Department escalator surrounding prominently also set up a security-related boarding warning signs.<br> <br>That the judge hearing the case, refers to the security obligations within reasonable limits organizer hotels, shopping malls, banks, railway stations, entertainment venues and other public places or mass activities due to make another person from physical or property damage obligations. If the organizer said in public places or mass activities not covered security obligations, causing damage to others, shall bear tort liability.<br> <br>Judgment of the Court that the plaintiff while riding the escalator upward outbound fall and hurt yourself, sued the defendant to bear the breach of security obligations tort liability on the grounds that the steep slope of the escalator provided by the accused, fast,http://store.shopping.yahoo.co.jp/ebest-dvd/0000000608832.html, and in the process of the plaintiff ride suddenly there beating, causing the plaintiff fell and injured. But according to the site surveillance video shows that the plaintiff take the escalator in the incident was running smoothly, there is no case of sudden beating.<br> <br>At the same time, the rated speed and angle of inclination of the escalators are in line with safety regulations, the defendant also set up security-related boarding warning labels, the defendant after the plaintiff injured staff quickly rushed to the scene for processing, and promptly sent to the plaintiff hospital where the defendant has done to the security obligations within reasonable limits range.<br> <br>Court ultimately found liable for infringement plaintiff requested the defendant lacked factual and legal basis. In accordance with the provisions of the first paragraph of Article 37 of the Tort Law, sentence the defendant to compensate the plaintiff MTRCL 8800 yuan,moncler femme, dismissed the plaintiff's other claims.<br> <br>Hangzhou newspaper November 13 electricity<br> <br>Drawing / Takaoka<br> <br>Link<br> <br>October at 22:20 on the 4th or so, Ms. Peng people Guangzhou, Guangdong Zhujiang New City subway station arrives,piumini woolrich outlet, take the escalator from the station platform. In the elevator to the line more than half the time, Ms. Peng suddenly rolled back and his mother both from the running elevators. Accidents resulting in two seriously injured. Ms Pang younger body multiple bruises fall, right waist and ankles sprain. Ms. Peng 73-year-old mother smashes his head and legs, bleeding.<br> <br>Ms. Peng recalls that he only "feel there was a pull back forces", then you fall seven dirty eight elements, "I think it is the elevator equipment suddenly shift."<br> <br>Guangzhou Metro officials said, according to surveillance video we judge, then lift handrails and steps are kept uniform state. Cause of the accident is likely to come from their own mother and daughter.<br> <br>□ say "law" public places, managers should make security obligations<br> <br>In recent years, similar to the use of public spaces when the elevator injured things have occurred, such cases not only affect individual lives and property of the masses, but also may lead to disputes conflicts, and even lead to public safety incidents. So, whether it is from the standpoint of protecting people's rights point of view, or from the Public Building a Safe Environment perspective, managers in public places due to security obligations, not only to ensure the safe operation of public facilities, to make prompt prior obligations,http://store.shopping.yahoo.co.jp/waiwai/g-300lv-7ajf.html, taking also into account the various problems that may occur, the development of adequate and feasible contingency plans. Yu Fei<br> <br>(Original title: Hangzhou Passenger Corporation v. The "first case" sentencing)<br> (Edit: SN067)<br>
DavidCadogan.ca Forums » DavidCadogan.ca
uyre2wFWTq
(1 post)-
Posted 10 years ago #
Reply
You must log in to post.